3.2.1 Disappearance of 16 farmers, Vannathivattai, 15th February 1993:
3.2.2 Disappearances and the resulting undercurrents in the social fabric.
3.3
The case of Zacky Nathaniel , Sinthathurai (Born 18th February 1969)
Duty officer, Legal Aid Centre, Bar Association, Colombo 12 18/4/91:
3.4 Muslims in the Batticaloa District
3.6
The Social Back Drop to the Shifting Military Balance in Batticaloa
3.7 Reports: Military Operations in the Batticaloa District
Kannankudah;
June 1993: Two LTTE girls killed in an ambush
Pavatkodichchenai,
19th October 1993:
Pavatkodichchenai,
6th November 1993:
Irunooruvil:
(2 miles from Pavatkodichchenai); 7th December 1993:
Official concern over the last 4 months
centred around the Presidential Mobile Secretariat scheduled for 23rd
July 1993. Its bungling as a public relations exercise exposed the general insensitivity
of the authorities. At one point masked informants were deployed at sentry points
and security arrangements such as regular nocturnal visits to homes in town
ensured that few were left undaunted to attend the PMS. When Minister Munsoor
apologised for the non-arrival of the chief guest, another minister contradicted
Munsoor in a belittling manner, suggesting the meaning that President Wijetunga
had more important things to do than to see the people of the East. The attack
on the fellow Easterner went down badly. When Prime Minister Wickremasinghe
attended briefly, security was taken so seriously that people got pushed around.
Where diplomacy was concerned all was not lost. A host
of village girls in police uniform from places like Polonnaruwa and Moneragala
were brought into Batticaloa. The village girls hit it off so well with children
around the place where they were staying, that people were afterwards prepared
to see them as very loving lot.One mishap occurred which many swear was why
the chief guest did not arrive. A child went to a temple festival and brought
home a lethal looking toy pistol. Seeing the child play with it, a police woman
mistakenly took it to be a real wepon and set off the alarm Kottiya avilla
(The Tigers have arrived). The area was surrounded and the cordon slowly closed
around a gaping boy holding his toy!
A young Sinhalese policeman went into
a house to eat his lunch packet and got into a conversation with the people
of the house who offered him extra curries. He explained that he was from Moneragala.
Lacking other means of employment his two elder brothers had gone into the army.
His parents had made him follow them into the army against his wishes. He later
deserted the army and joined the police. He has not told his colleagues that
his name was on the army lists as one among several thousand deserters, who
were subject to arrest by the police.
It became evident in the relative thaw that prevails
now that Muslims, Sinhalese and Tamils can all get on very well as ordinary
people. Although no political alternative has presented itself, there is deep
disillusionment among ordinary people with ideologies of group exclusivism that
are at the root of the conflict.
If the security forces find themselves
in a quagmire because of the moral collapse of the state, the Tigers too are
paying a heavy price for their past. The Tigers being picked off, often by fellow
villagers from groups they violently alienated, are most often young boys who
joined the LTTE after June 199O through fear of the army. Recent military successes
for the LTTE have drawn attention away from its deep crisis.
A disturbing undercurrent that is widely talked about
is the ubiquity of corruption. Compared with widespread extortion by the LTTE
two years ago, there is hardly any talk of it now in the town area. The visible
face of extortion is now worn by Tamil groups working with government forces
and there are many testimonies to this. Farmers for instance bring in rice from
the interior and sell it to Muslim traders at Valayiravu bridge. When one farmer
came to the bridge, a Tamil militant at a the sentry point asked the Muslim
trader to hand over to him the payment due to the farmer. Had the Tamil farmer
protested, he would have been invariably arrested as an LTTE sympathiser. The
Muslim trader tried unsuccessfully to shield the farmer by saying that he had
unsold stocks and would need time to procure the money. In the end the entire
price of Rs. 26OOO/- was paid to the militant. An obvious question is why such
things are allowed to happen in public view under the very noses of the authorities?
One is hardly surprised when leading citizens allude
to a more insidious invisible network of corruption and extortion that uses
the draconian powers that are available to the state machinery. Testimonies
include large sums of money passed on to leading security officials through
intermediaries for the release of detainees and extortion and protection rackets
where private gain smoothly intermingles with local UNP politics. The SSP
is seen not as a government servant but as a UNP organiser.There is a deep
sense of fear among those caught up in this. [Some police transfers had since
taken place. But talk of corruption among the forces is still widespread.] [Top]
Early morning on this day army personnel
believed to be from the Karadianaru camp rounded up 17 persons comprising an
elderly watcher, 15 farmers from Puthukkudiyiruppu and one from Thalankudah.
Some sources say that the army had come on information to the effect that these
farmers were harvesting fields cultivated for the LTTE. Another source said
that the soldiers who had first lain in ambush for the LTTE, were later ambushed
by the LTTE and were in a bad mood. The fields concerned were irrigated by the
Unnichchai and Rugam tanks and were off the Chenkaladi - Maha Oya Road. The
womenfolk who were in the wadis protested. The soldiers promised to release
the men after inquiry. The women however followed the prisoners. The soldiers
threatened them with the gun and sent them back. Except for the old caretaker
who was released, the other detainees have not been accounted for.
The matter had been raised by the
MPs and the Batticaloa Peace Committee. But the Brigade Commander in charge
of Batticaloa has continued to deny that any such incident took place. A senior
member of the Peace Committee told the brigadier, We have always played
straight with you. If we say someone was taken, then he or she was taken. Now
come on, this incident was witnessed and the men were taken away by army personnel
in uniform. This member said that unlike on an earlier occasion when the
duty roster was called for by the second in command to check on units moving
in a given area at the given time of interest, the brigadier seemed reluctant
to do it on this occasion. But he maintained the denial. Another member of the
Peace Committee said that the army later said that the roster was checked and
there was no relevant record.
A second member of the Peace Committee said that most
disappearances reported to them upto about mid-1991 are not accounted for. But
that after this date many cases reported to them were later released. Since
many of them lived in the rural areas only a small fraction of the releases
were reported to them. They now had close to 54OO cards, he said, but are unable
to give the exact number of the disappeared. Asked about a large number of disappearances
reported in the Tamil press as having taken place in recent months (middle of
1993) towards the Polonnaruwa border, he said that the area was more than 2O
miles from Batticaloa. The Peace Committee had contacts in Valaichenai who often
sent them people in need of help. Thus relatives of a fraction of persons detained
from those parts and even from places like Kallar, Mandur and the Amparai District,
regularly lodged complaints with the Batticaloa Peace Committee. He added that
while he cannot say anything definite, if the phenomenon was significant, they
would normally have got wind of it. [Top]
A queue of persons whose near ones
had disappeared was waiting to make representations before the Presidential
Mobile Secretariat. The mood among these grey haired emaciated folk was one
of sullen defiance. One of them told the others not to expect anything from
this exercise adding, Avan engal inaththai Kooru pottu vikkiran
(They are dividing our kind like chopped fish in a market and selling us down
the drain). Why were then these people there? These lean and hungry folk were
determined to go on until the mighty got off their seats and said either a simpleyes
or no to whether or not they killed their sons and daughters.
So far the issue has been fudged.
There is, as the Peace Committee spokesman pointed out, no absolute accountability.
Anyone could disappear today as much as happened three years ago if anyone in
authority fancies it. By refusing to face up to it, the government continues
to lose legitimacy while something unpleasant is brewing below.
The lack of any word about the disappeared
has multiplied the misery in families several fold. Even after more than seven
years people wait in hope, minutely examining every rumour of the loved one
having been seen somewhere, leading a restless existence. This is true of all
cases whether the party responsible was a state force or one of the Tamil groups.
In such families education is disrupted and one sees intelligent children stagnating.
If the leaders of the party responsible could just come down to saying We
are sorry. Your son is no more. Please allow us to help you get over it,
it would go long way. If not a volcano may erupt where and when it is least
expected.
How complex and tragic the problem
is, is close to the surface in every village. The case of the Vyramuththu family
with 3 boys and 6 girls is not untypical. The eldest son Dr.Vyramuththu Thayaseelan
disappeared after being taken by the STF at Kallady in 1985. The second boy
Uthayaseelan then joined the EPRLF and was taken prisoner when the LTTE took
on the EPRLF in December 1986. He was among those executed by the LTTE in their
Jaffna Kanthan Karunai camp four months later. The third brother Elango was
in the conscripted Tamil National Army and was among the many TNA cadre killed
by the LTTE in concert with the Sri Lankan forces. One sister was engaged to
Jeyadevan taken in by the late Mr. Theophilus, D.I.G., Police, when he came
looking for his brother Beto, a member of the TELO. Jeyadevan was killed while
escaping. Another sister was registered to Kandasamy, a security guard in the
Eastern University. He was one of the 158 who disappeared on 5th
September 199O after being taken away by troops under Brigadier P.A. Karunatilleke.
Out of the five members of the family who disappeared, no corpse or any other
trace was seen by the family. [Top]
How persevering most parents are in
trying to trace disappeared sons is reflected in many instances. We give one
which also exposes the hollowness of the machinery intended to provide redress.
Zacky was an A.Level student and senior prefect at the Jesuit run St. Michaels
College Batticaloa. Shortly after the army entered he was taken from his residence
in Lake Road in a general round up on 5th July 199O and released.
He went home and was talking to a friend at the entrance when he was again picked
up by uniformed army personnel. His companions in Batticaloa prison saw him
last on 12th July 199O and are aware that two prisoners were taken
away in the night. Zackys arrest was witnessed by neighbours including
his mother Therese (53) and sister Jennet who is fluent in all three languages
and has also taught in Sinhalese schools.
The father, K.Sinthathurai (61), a
carpenter, has a file full of documents and letters of acknowledgement from
the both governmental and non-governmental bodies witnessing his search. He
said apologetically that he has even more letters at home besides those in his
file. He accomplished the unusual task of obtaining a police report authenticated
by an officer of the CIB, Batticaloa (25th July 199O). The ICRC and
the Batticaloa Peace Committee were among the first to be informed. Here are
some of the responses received by him.
Joseph Pararajasingham MP:
26/2/91: Copy of letter to Air Chief Marshal Walter Fernando, Secretary/Defence,
enclosing affidavit.
Mrs. R.M.Pulendran MP, State Minister
for Education: 6/2/92: Copy of letter to General Wanasinghe.
Please await further communication.
Informed Organiser Foreign Peace Committee
on circuit in Batticaloa. 11/1O/91.
A.M. Weerakoon, Secretary to Presidential
Commission of Inquiry into Involuntary Removal of Persons: 4/9/91: Regret
outside terms of reference as published in the Gazatte Extraordinary No. 644/27
of 11/1/91.
S.Wijewardene, Human Rights Task
Force: 6/2/92: Will keep a lookout for him
in the course of visiting camps to prepare comprehensive register.
Civil Information Officer, Commissioner
General of Essential Services: Colombo: 12/3/91: Acknowledged complaint on a
cyclostyled letter.
For Secretary/Defence at Presidential
Mobile Secretariat in Batticaloa: 1/3/93: Acknowledged complaint by mother,
K.S.Jennet.
Civil Affairs,for General Officer
Commanding,Joint Operations Command,Colombo 3:
27/5/93, to K.S. Jennet: It
is reported that a person by this name was not taken into custody by the security
forces.
Some letters contained lines like:
If you have further information, please do not hesitate to contact us.
Many have taken the whole exercise to mean that while huge resources are being
spent, mostly on public relations, the onus for the actual search and conclusions
is with the relatives. The mother goes to church every week, lights candles
and prays for the restoration of her missing son. Most of these complaints directed
through different routes, no doubt end up in what is literally the waste paper
basket at the Ministry of Defence. In this case, like in the case of over 17O
persons taken from the Eastern University, the government would have had no
problem in giving an answer if it wanted to.
There are two significant events in
Zackys past possibly connected with his disappearance. During the IPKF
presence a member of the TELO was being a bit of a nuisance to a school girl
at St. Michaels. Zacky as a prefect pulled him up. Zacky was later taken
to a TELO camp and the father summoned. Zacky was then released. He skipped
his A.Levels that year because he could not concentrate. When Zacky was missing
after his arrest in July 199O, his sister who had taught in Wattala, made contact
with the famous Captain Munas at Batticaloa Prison on a morning. Munas called
for the prison register and perused the names. He then asked the family to return
at 4 oclock in the evening. When they returned they were told that Munas
was out. The father dreaded trying again and gave up this line of search. [Top]
Following Zackys disappearance,
Jennets husband Colvin went off to Colombo and then to Switzerland. After
receiving news about Zacky, his brother Rocky Barnes (26) then in Oman was anxious
to see his parents. The father did not want the son to come to Batticaloa, but
had intended to meet him in Colombo upon his arrival in December 199O. The arrangements
went wrong and Rocky suddely turned up in Batticaloa. His father sent him packing
telling him not to remain one day in Batticaloa. Rocky too went to Switzerland.
Very little of the fear felt by ordinary Tamils is reflected in the Sri Lankan
press which is now (August 1993) in a state of undisguised glee over plans to
send back Tamils from Europe. In recent times we have been treated to more features
from Europe from where these refugees may be sent back and almost none from
Pottuvil, Batticaloa or Trincomalee where they originate, and which are easy
of access if the press is in the least interested.
One hopes European governments
will not talk of deportation until there is accountability, and not costly public
relations, over disappearances, and tangible assurances that they will not happen
again. Also people like Mr. & Mrs. Sinthathurai should be told officially
what became of their son, so that they could burn their files full of standard
English evasion and start life anew. [Top]
The worst hit among the Muslims are the paddy cultivators
who have been without an income for more than 3 years. Some started receiving
rent for their fields from Tamil cultivators when the army moved into the interior.
Muslim traders are also moving into the interior and staying overnight in villages
like Kokkadichcholai. Talks are still going on about Muslim farmers returning
to their fields in the interior. Tamils in that area expect the outcome to be
positive. A Muslim elder remarked, We are people from this area and we
have to live with the Tamils. If the government can talk to the LTTE in 5 star
hotels, who can tell us not to talk to them in order to protect our livelihood?
Only a small fraction of cattle owned by Muslims has been traced.
Some of the current anxieties of the
Muslims concern education and administration. Although Tamil doctors and hospital
staff have returned to Muslim areas, not so with the teachers. For this reason
most Muslim schools are handicapped in the teaching of Science and English.
Some Muslim children have returned to big schools in Batticaloa town. Others
rich enough have sent theirs to places like Kalmunai, Gampola, Mawanella and
Colombo. With regard to administration there is a general feeling that although
moves to get rid of administrators from Jaffna in favour of people of local
origin was largely successful, Muslims are now more discriminated against. Further
the general trend towards homogeneous AGA (DS) divisions, ethnic appointments
and the fact that Muslims while living in compact areas have their economic
life outside has resulted in Muslims who are 25% of the district population
having AGA divisions comprising less than 5% of the land area. Since land alienation
for agricultural and residential purposes is now a subject originating with
the AGA (Divisional Secretary), the Muslims are now at a disadvantage. Although
there was a clamour for new Muslim AGA divisions when there was an intense security
threat, there are now considerable reservations. These are similar to Tamil
reservations about the Divisional Secretariat system in the Trincomalee District
where recently many thinly populated Sinhalese divisions were carved out.
Settlement in Mahaveli System B along the Polonnaruwa District border
A Muslim administrator was questioned about anxieties
expressed by Tamil leaders that Tamil applicants have not been called for while
moves are going ahead to settle the Muslims as a buffer between Sinhalese and
Tamils. This system of placing the Muslims in an unenviable position, which
presupposes the permanence of conflict, was one of the contributory factors
behind the massacres of April - October 1992. The administrator in Eravur explained
that 5O Muslim families from the village were given allotments between 1983
and 199O. A further 5O were given land after December 1991 up to August 1993.
These were from MPs quotas. He said that the allottees were not keen on accepting,
but did so because they have been mostly unable to cultivate around Eravur since
1985. Even so they were not going to live permanently on the Mahaveli lands,
he said, besides the profits have been very low.
It is remarkable that despite a number
of organisations being present in the area, the single peace effort bringing
unforseen success, without having intended to be one, was marked by the visit
of Moulana Abdul Cader [See Report No11]. One reason was that the visit
co-incided with a rising practical realisation by both communities of the need
to co-exist. Also remarkable is the fact that the thaw came less than a year
after the LTTE published a threatening article against the Muslims in its European
journal Kalathilin mid 1992 and the Palliyagodelle (Pallithidal)
massacre of October 1992. There is perhaps also a realisation that the LTTEs
present discomfiture in the district has nothing to do with the Muslims, but
rather has much to do with the tragedy within the Tamil community of which it
(the LTTE) was the main author. Increasing openness is also to be discerned
among the Tamils, many of whom blame the LTTEs actions against the Muslims
as being among the chief causes of their own sufferings.
Local reports that the ICRC now acts
only in cases where the person detained has not been released for more than
24 hours confirms the general improvement reflected in Report
11. However there is much that remains unchanged. It is still common, if
not always the case, for those arrested on the basis of suspicion or false information
to be beaten for about 5 days and kept for an indefinite period - sometimes
for money. A detainee released after a month said that he was allowed to go
only because he had caught an infection. He had been detained on the charge
that he took provisions to the Tigers. Conditions under which women taken in
for questioning are held could be extremely crude. Recent cases of rape and
molestation in police custody are known, against which preventive measures could
be weak and mainly at the discretion of the OIC.
Informed sources said that in early
August 1993 there were 97 prisoners on the ground floor of Batticaloa prison,
being interrogated under suspicion. There were upstairs about 45 prisoners,
who were said to have surrendered after deserting the LTTE, many with their
weapons. This trend is an indication of the LTTEs troubles in the area.
The ex-LTTE prisoners are said to have become obese, eating good food and constantly
watching videos. It is said that these could go home if they wished. All these
prisoners receive regular visits from the ICRC, about which they are happy.
[The trend of surrenders has continued into the spring of 1994 and these are
now more widely talked about.]
A particular case which caused some
alarm was the detention of about a dozen of women from Batticaloa taken to Kandy
and Nuwara Eliya for training by the Womens Development Centre during
mid-July 1993. The affair originated with one or more of the questioning of
a girl Somawathy from Kallar living in Batticaloa and the detection of a letter
to her from one of the girls Meena on the programme, also from Kallar, mentioning
the word training. It has also been suggested that one of the three
girls being questioned had done a spell in Boosa for alleged militant involvement.
The conditions under which the girls, including 3 instructresses, were held
by the Kandy police caused alarm. When being transported to Batticaloa, to be
held in the Forestry Camp, the girls were held needlessly for a night in the
Polonnaruwa jungles, where they felt very frightened. One of those beaten by
the police in the affair is said to be a Sinhalese driver in the WDC. All except
two of the girls concerned were released after a magistrates inquiry 4
or 5 days later.
A spokesman for the Batticalaoa Peace
Committee said that to inquiries made by them, the girls had not complained
of ill - treatment. He said that there had been a case of rape at the Forestry
Camp un-connected with this affair, in which medical examination proved too
late for verification. Orders, he said, had been given to OIC Nethasinghe to
place an officer under arrest. The spokesman added that the Peace Committee
always advised people taking groups out to contact the SP and obtain formal
clearance - something that could save unnecessaryy trouble. [Top]
Hardly anyone on the ground disagrees that the LTTE
is in trouble in the Batticaloa District, despite this ongoing attrition to
its fortunes being hidden by sensational successes like in Weli Oya(and later
in Puneryn). Two years ago extortion by the LTTE in Batticaloa town was much
talked about. Well known were suburbs where LTTE cadre could be regularly encountered.
At present LTTE movement even in villages just across the lagoon, near the west
bank, are severely restricted. LTTE cadre come unarmed in ones and twos by day
in civilian dress carrying at most a pistol or a grenade. Thanks to the attitude
of the government and the terrible behaviour of groups with its forces, the
LTTE does retain some legitimacy. But people feel less inhibited about criticising
it. That its agenda has little to do with the well-being of the people is understood.
That it set off a mine two years ago in Kokkadichcholai and allowed a handful
of soldiers to burn, loot, kill and to rape for several hours without firing
even a warning shot, and came the following day to take photographs has not
been forgotten. The government too continues to be seen as callous and has done
nothing to win back trust. The cry for Eelam remains a strong driving force
to a people who have lost so much and think of a separate state as the only
means to arrest their steady decline and powerlessness. Why does the LTTE find
itself in difficulties?
It has as mentioned nothing to do with
the Muslims. It has little directly to do with the Sri Lankan army. The Sri
Lankan army is mostly in camps, making an occasional sweep with 3OO-4OO men
and, now and then setting up ambushes on receipt of information. One sees little
of the competent soldiering and intense foot patrolling of the IPKF. Some villages
do not see the army for several weeks at a time.
The answer has much to do with what
the LTTE did to Tamil society from 1986 by its attacks on other groups. In the
Batticaloa District among other places the resulting deep sense of disillusionment
is part of an intense tragedy. They know that their sons are stalking each other
and blood is flowing to no purpose. Worst of all there is no force offering
a politics of healing. Much of the hunting locally is being done by the TELO
and a splinter group of the PLOTE led by (PLOTE) Mohan [see Report
11, Chapter 6]. One source put the strength of these groups operating around
Batticaloa at 5OO. Others deem the number possible, but as probably being on
the high side. With army camps in strategic locations these groups seem confident
enough to move about in small numbers like four.
A man in his early 5Os who is a government
servant is known to his colleagues as the father of a Tiger area leader and
take that as indicating the main thrust of his loyalties. But talking to him,
the basis of his interests and motivations is far from simple. His eldest son
was in the Tamil National Army. When the TNA was hunted by the LTTE as the IPKF
left in late 1989, the father got the son into the Reserve Police. The son was
posted in the North when the June 199O war began and fled to Colombo with his
colleagues who escaped. He was jobless for 7 months. The father approached an
inspector of police and got him reinstated. Another of his sons was a good student
who obtained 3 As for his O Levels and was taking tuition for English and Mathematics
which he had failed. When the war of June 199O began, he joined the LTTE out
of fear of being killed by the incoming Sri Lankan Forces. The estimates of
those who joined different groups from the village conform to the general pattern
in the East. From this village about 25 joined the PLOTE before 1987 and about
25 the LTTE after June 199O, of whom about 9 have been killed (August 1993).
Thus the son of this man who joined the LTTE may be stalked by his own nephew.
His second son is at home afraid to go out and farm. Whenever someone from the
LTTE visits the village, information reaches the other groups in a short time.
The mans family is regularly harassed. His wishes have little of the colourful
rhetoric of the LTTE leadership: I want peace so that I could get my son
back home, send him to the Eastern Technical Institute, and train him to repair
vehicles.
In Mahiladitivu, once considered an
LTTE stronghold, the feelings are mixed. The association is also connected with
the LTTE leader Kumarappa marrying there. But the village also has associations
which give the people other lines of thought. The village also produced Vasudeva,
a prominent PLOTE leader, and Paramadeva, a well known LTTE leader, who were
brothers. Paramadeva was killed during an unsuccessful attack on the Kaluwanchikkudy
police station in 1985. Vasudeva was killed by the LTTE during the small interlude
of peace soon after the IPKF arrived in July 1987. Vasudeva and 11 companions
were unarmed and were returning after a swim in Pasikudah by van when they were
gunned down. The LTTE had also shown its callousness during the Kokkadichcholai
massacre. The number joining the LTTE from the village now is said to be almost
nil. Among the surrendered LTTE cadre in the Batticaloa prison, about 15 are
said to be from Kokkadichcholai. Surrender, rather than recruitment, appears
to be now the more significant trend.
The disillusionment here is therefore
born of a very intimate experience of tragedy. The presence of the Sri Lankan
army, though as a repressive force, has given people space to think. But the
LTTE will hold some ground because there is no political force to offer ideas
responsive to their deeper needs - the first being to stop their sons stalking
each other. [Top]
The pattern of operations continues
the trend described in the Report 11. A typical army sweep through Paduvankarai
was as described below:
On 29th July at 6.OO A.M.
about 2OO or 3OO soldiers came to the village of Pavatkodichchenai and called
out the villagers. All passers by were stopped among whom was a baker. With
the army were 3 armed persons in trousers described as either PLOTE or TELO
and an unarmed LTTE deserter. The deserter identified the bread man as one who
supplied the LTTE. He was then beaten by the Tamil militants. The baker replied
that he supplied the army and of course on occasions some young men stopped
him and bought bread and it was not his to ask who they were. The captain got
Unichchai camp on the wireless and verified the bread mans first claim.
The Tiger deserter kept assaulting the bread man telling him, You liar,
you sold me bread. The captain was riding around on the bicycle of one
of those stopped, nominally telling the militants every time he passed not to
beat the wretch, but to little effect. A village elder standing there attributed
the behaviour of the non-LTTE groups to virakthi (frustration and
alienation). About 7.3O A.M. those going to school, including the principal,
were released. All were later released except the poor bread man who could not
choose his customers.
We note down some of the other typical
incidents.
Pavatkodichchenai: April 1993:
A senior LTTE member, Lal, was visiting his wife and family. The army acting
on information rounded up the place at 2.OO A.M. Lal was held and his hands
tied. The army was waiting for dawn to move out. Lal gathered from the conversation
between soldiers that he was to be finished off. When Lals hands were
untied in the morning for him to go to the toilet, he hit a soldier on the jaw
and escaped. In the resulting firing and confusion it is reported that one soldier
was injured and possibly one killed. Lals wife and mother were unhurt.
During July, the local school principal was beaten up by Tamil militants for
employing Lals wife as a volunteer teacher. The latter now lives in Batticaloa.
Navatkadu 9th June:
When the army first arrived in July 199O, 14 were taken away and about 3 were
released. Thereafter several youths joined the LTTE from what was earlier a
mostly PLOTE village. Among those who joined from the area were three friends
Anatus (born 1972), Atputhan and Mathan. At the time above Atputhan came to
the village for collection of money and was returning to Karaveddy 5 miles away
when he was ambushed by members of a group close to the army. The body was brought
in a tractor to Anatus place. The father and brother immediately slipped
away. The dead body was brought into the hall, dumped in front of the mother
and married sister. A shot was fired into the head and was taken away after
the mother was told that this would be the fate of her son too.
Mathan was later ambushed at Mahilavedduwan
9 miles away. The body was brought to Navatkadu by tractor. On finding no one
at Anatus place, it was taken to the hospital and burnt under the Tiger
news board (The Tigers Roar). Earlier another LTTE member Mano was ambushed.
Mano escaped with a leg injury and was taken to Jaffna for treatment. During
May 1993, armed persons walked into Anatus home when the mother and sister
were at home and walked away with about Rs 8OOO/- worth of items.
During early July members of other
groups arrested Karukka (23) a former LTTE supporter and father of two, who
is now held in Batticaloa prison.
Mandapathady; early July 1993:
The school sports meet was going on and Mahapody was the announcer. (PLOTE)
Mohan came with 3 others on 3 motorcycles. One was wearing a red scarf. They
grabbed Mahapody, while other villagers tried to grab him back. Mahapody was
taken to Batticaloa prison and released a few weeks later. Villagers take it
for granted that money was paid - the time being just after the harvest. Mohan
had given summons earlier to Mahapody to meet him at Batticaloa Prison. Mahapody
had been afraid to travel past sentry points because he had lost his identity
card.
Navatkudah: Over a year ago the TELO had shot and killed a lady on hearing that
she had visited her son in the LTTE [See Report No9]. On the same night
a lady GS who visited her husband in the LTTE was also killed. Her two younger
sons, 1O & 5 years of age, were then brought up by an uncle who was a peon
in the Fisheries. Their father, a carpenter in Mannar, has not visited Batticaloa
for a long while. Recently, the 1O year old boy joined the LTTE, upon hearing
which the TELO beat up the uncle. The eldest in the family, a girl, had joined
the LTTE in 1989.
Outskirts of Batticaloa; July:
Two policemen on picketing duty along the railroad went to a house where they
frequently drank water. One policeman who was very friendly with the children
of the area was strumming his automatic imagining it to be a guitar. The other
warned him against it. When a school boy brought water, the gun went off killing
the boy. The policeman tried to shoot himself and was prevented by the people.
He then went on knocking his head against the wall until he was taken away.
Kokkadichcholai; Late June:
Mahendran (26) who was earlier in the EPRLF and now in the TELO came home for
his sons first birthday. The home was near the army camp and the previous
night friends and relatives were decorating. His friend, recently arrived from
the Middle - East was helping. Two men in civil smoking cigarettes came home
and asked for Mahendran. Mahendran sensing something amiss quickly hid in the
ceiling. The men called the friend and shot him. Mahendrans wife
in a state of advanced pregnancy, ran to the aid of the friend. The intruders
fired again, killing her as well. The general talk was that the killers belonged
to the LTTE. Other rumours were also being spread to the effect that the incident
resulted from a feud among friends. An old lady who attended the funeral said
that there was no doubt about the killers and moreover that the LTTE had sent
its regrets over the killing of the expectant mother.
Mavady Munmari; 27th
June 1993: The LTTE was holding court sessions in
the village. LTTE courts are said to be preferred by farmers to the normal courts
because disputes were quickly settled. Unknown to those involved, the army on
receipt of information had set up an ambush the previous night. The army opened
fire killing 3. One source in the area said that all killed were LTTE men. Another
said that one was a civilian.
Chenkalady - Pankudaveli Road;
Mid-July: Special forces acting on information went
to a wadi where 6 LTTE members were hidden and opened fire. 4 died while 2 escaped.
Rugam; 17th September
1993: Narayanapillai Illango (23), a farmer, was
taken by the army from Unnichchai and is still missing.
Paduvankarai ; About September
1993: Three young men accused of helping the LTTE,
one from Ichchantivu, one from Soruwamunai and Adiyan from Mahilavedduwn were
reported killed by the Mohan group. The body of Adiyan a former member of the
EROS is said to have been cut into 16 pieces.
Pavatkodichchenai (near Unnichchai,
Paduvankarai (West of Lagoon)); 16th October 1993: Area
surrounded by army and Albert Master was shot dead and his man Kanapathipillai(
aged 7O),married in Koththiavalai was injured. Albert Master was a kind of organiser
for the LTTE who did some teaching, facilitated recruitment and arranged supplies.
Kanpathipillai was used to carry supplies into the interior and was known locally
as Kadaththal Appu (Old Smuggler).On 14th November a
shop owned by Maniam, a man of Indian origin, which was next to the nursery
run by Albert Master was broken into by the army and the goods removed. The
nursery was on premises owned by a Muslim from Eravur now effectively debarred
from the area.
Padukadu (Deep Jungle), 2 miles
from Pavatkodichchenai; 18th October 1993: 7 persons sleeping in a hut, of whom 4 were LTTE members were apprehended
by the army who surrounded the place during the night. Two, including the owner
of the hut, were released after a beating during which they sustained fractures.
Five, including Susiharan (alias Anatus, the area leader of Navatkadu referred
to earlier), were taken to the Commathurai Army Camp . Sooty, one of the five,
who had left the LTTE, married, had two children and was expecting the 3rd,
was later sent to Batticaloa prison. The remaining 4 are not accounted for.
Other sources said that Susiharan was taken to the notorious centre in Batticaloa
by (ex-) PLOTE Mohan who personally went to Commathurai and asked for him. There
is grave concern over the fate of these four.
Koppalapillai Ravindran who was disabled in both hands
was the owner of a shop where some passing LTTE boys had once slept. On this
day the army had asked a number of people to report to the Unichchai army camp
for a meeting. Ravindran who went was detained.
7 Persons sleeping in a house, some
of whom had an LTTE involvement, were apprehended by the army. Two were released.
The fate of the rest is unknown.
Uppuryankulam, 8th November
1993: A new army camp was installed using some of
the personnel from Unichchai. The army then went into Pavatkkodichchenai and
broke down about 13 houses whose occupants had evacuated during the troubles
to obtain materials for the camp. The owner of two of the houses being broken
protested. The army continued breaking promising to return the materials when
the camp is withdrawn.
Pavatkodichchenai, 18th November 1993:
The army from Uppurayankulam entered the house of Rasiah Vethanantham during
the night, and asked for him. His wife said that she would bring him to the
camp in the morning. The soldiers flashed a light, scolded the wife and took
Vethanantham away. Previously his cousin-brother Jeyakanthan who was taken in
for questioning when asked to come out with names had mentioned Vethananthams.
Vethanantham was beaten for 7 days with poles on his chest, back and feet. The
camp authorities denied for 5 days his arrest to his wife who kept going to
the camp. After ten days, he was transferred to Batticaloa Prison, from where
he was released after a further ten days.
After returning home Vethanantham was in no condition
to work. 4 acres that he had sown with rice, chlolam (Indian corn) and Payaru(
green gram) were lost because he was arbitrarily detained at a time when some
crucial operations in cultivation had to be undertaken.In addition to his crop
he had also lost 2 houses broken down by the army. Such is the fate of many
farmers and their families in the area as we approach 4 years of pacification
and the return of democracy. In most cases the reasons why people
are picked up and tortured are even sillier and far less explicable.
Vethanantham s cousin Jeyakanthan
refered to was a 13 year old who had once for the thrill of it accompanied Albert
Master (see 16th October above) on a trip. After he returned, he
was arrested by the army on a tip-off.
Thumpalai (Unnichchai area, 1 ½
miles from Pavatkodichchenai); Late November 1993: Sivasambu Podiar
(6O), Lingan, Mahrasa(25) and Moothavan (25) were detained by the army. The
last two had been released within 2 weeks.
Kalaipottamadu; 27th
November 1993: On the 26th night 4 LTTE
men organised a celebration of the Leaders birthday. At 4.3O AM two LTTE
men escorted the speaker for the occasion out of the village. While returning
the two were shot dead by the army waiting in ambush. The other two in the village
attempted to escape. The leader who had Rs 23 OOO/- of collections on his person
was shot dead. The other escaped.
Sillikkudiaru (Munthiraiyadippallam
on Kokkadichcholai Road); 27th November
1993: LTTE men came into the village, gathered the villagers and proceeded
to celebrate their leader Prabakarans birthday which fell on the previous
day. The army under the officer from the Unnichchai camp which had encircled
the village the previous night closed in. On seeing them approach, the villagers
mixed with the LTTE and created confusion. The officer restrained his men from
opening fire. In the meantime the LTTE escaped through a gap in the cordon.
This was one instance of commendable restraint on the part of the army.
Paduvankarai; November 1993:
About 2O members of the LTTE, including Podi, a man in the finance section carrying
a large sum from tax collections, were moving towards Jaffna by
the interior jungle tracts. Somewhere near Unnichchai they reached a rock and
2 of the party were sent to obtain bread. The main party was surrounded by the
army which had received a tip off. The LTTEers scattered leaving behind loads
of baggage including the money. Subsequently the LTTE relieved Podi of his job.
Fearing further punishment, Podi surrendered to the army and is said to have
given many names of persons from whom taxes were collected. Many among them,
it is reported, were nominated by the army as candidates in its own
Independent Groups for the local elections held on 1st March
1994. They were in turn summoned by the LTTE to whom they explained their position.
Three businessmen said to have been named by Podi were taken to prison for possible
extortion. Mohan reportedly berated them, Neengal Yarlpani! (You
all are Jaffnese).
One man so ruined is said to be Jeyapal
from Ichchantivu, adjoining Navatkadu. Besides having his head cropped, he is
said to have been asked to pay Rs.6 lakhs. He had paid Rs.3 Lakhs after selling
much of his property. Another LTTE member who had surrendered took the army
to a house near Vantharumoolai where he claimed he was fed.
Unnichchai; 6th December
1993: Three old men, including Pari Podi aged 7O
from Munaikkadu had gone about 12 miles into the interior in search of cattle.
When they did not return others went in search of them. At one place they found
Pari Podis betel leaf vessel (vettilai kinni) and his cloth shawl. Blood
stains leading away from the spot suggested that the old men had been shot and
dragged away. After another two days, 9th December, the villagers
gave up the search for the bodies. The nature of the signs point to the army.
The village whose name literally means
2OO fields had earlier belonged to Muslims and was later bought over by Tamils.
This is probably another of those land transactions influenced by security exigencies
of the kind remembered with bitterness by whichever community that was affected.
On the night in question a cow-herd Pakiarasa, a married man of about 35 years,
was out minding his cattle. On the approach of an army patrol he was heard shouting
Maadu (cows) to indicate his business. He was later missing and
his arrest was denied. His identity card, shirt and bicycle were found. The
ICRC was informed.
Siththandy: Christmas Eve 1993 : Soldiers said to be from the Independent Brigade detained
at 2.OO p.m. 16 farmers working near Santhanamadu River in Koddaikadu. 11 were
released the following day. The remaining 5 are still missing. They are with
their ages: Tharmalingam Rajeswaran (18) Kathirkamathamby Karunakaran (2O),
Kathiravel Chitravel Sivkumar (16), Konesapillay Sathiarajah (14) and Perian
Sivalingam (35). Rajani, the mother of Sivakumar sought advice and was directed
to the army camp at Pulipanjakal. She subsequently reported that her son was
not there.
The Batticaloa Peace Committee took up the matter with
Brigadier Gunawardene during the second week of March. The Brigadier reportedly
asked an army officer in the area to obtain statements from those released.
The officer, it is said, reported back to the Brigadier that the parties concerned
were unwilling to make a statement. The Brigadier is said to have retorted,
I ordered you to get a statement, not to request them for one !
Vellavelly; 26th December
1993: David of Vellavelly was killed by the STF
and his body was later recovered from Kaluwanchikudy hospital. An affidavit
was produced in parliament by Joseph Pararajasingam,MP.
Palugamam; 26th December
1993: The army went to the house of a boy whose
name had arisen in connection with an LTTE member who was apprehended. The boy
was shot and his body burnt.
Kathiravelly; 1Oth Janurary 1994:
Sellathurai Vimalanathan from Ninthavur was staying with his relation who was
GS (Village Headman) at Kathiravelly and was working there as a volunteer teacher.
He was helping his mother K. Sinnamuththu, an attendant at Ninthavur hospital
to look after his 4 siblings. Vimalanathan was taken by the army who raided
the house at mid - night and was sent to Batticaloa Prison about a month later
after the usual works. He may be another of the hundreds detained for no good
reason, possibly disabled and sent to a reformatory for years in place of the
miscreant authorities.
Munaikkadu; Early February 1994:
An LTTE helper living with a woman estranged from her husband was in a boat
with two others at 7.3O A.M plying his trade of lagoon fishing.(Ex-) PLOTE Mohan
appeared on the shore and called the man by name. As the boat came ashore Mohan
fired with his pistol and hit the man on his thigh. The man pleaded in an attitude
of worship. When the boat touched the shore Mohan shot him through the temple.
While passing the victims house on his way out, Mohan called the mans
companion and asked her to perform the funerary rites.
Chippimadu; Mid February 1994:
This is a village from which a number of persons had joined the LTTE. The army
went in and took 15 persons including at least one expectant mother to the Unnichchai
camp. The harvested paddy stored in some of the houses was also stolen by the
army, including from the house of none Jeevaratnam. The persons were later released
- the men 15 days later after being beaten.
Kathiravelly; 4th week
of February: In this village a few miles south of
the Verugal river, the army camp is to the east (sea side) of the main road
running south-north.The elementary school is to the west of the road and the
jungle further west borders the village. The schools morning session was
interrupted by a fire fight between the LTTE and an army patrol in the jungle
beyond. Soldiers in the camp rushed from across the road and began assaulting
the school children, causing them to scamper. Four children, ages 14 and below,
did not get home that day. They arrived home two days later having spent two
nights in the jungle without food or water. They had feared to return home earlier
because they would have had to pass within view of the army camp while crossing
the road.
At least 4 persons are missing from
Kathiravelly. The four had gone fishing shortly after the army encamped there
in 1992.
Eravur; 24th February:
Theivanayagam Chandrakumar and Veerakuty Mathan were taken by the police. When
asked by the parents of Chandrakumar, the police promised that they would be
released. Mathans relatives were allowed visits. Yuan Fonseka Catherina,
the mother of Chandrakumar approached Joseph Pararajasingam, MP, on 4th
March. When contacted by him ASP Kudahetty first denied the arrest. The MP then
threatened to take up the matter with the Defence Ministry. Kudahetty then came
out with a different story. He said that while Chandrakumar was leading the
police to an arms cache, there was a confrontation with the LTTE in which Chandrakumar
was fatally wounded. The Police had evidently cremated the body without a post
mortem. This piece of Police fiction was published in the Island.
Kanjirankuda; About 7th
March: The victim, once an LTTE helper, was in the
fields with other farmers threshing the newly harvested paddy. A gun man , dressed
as farmer, but identified as a member of the TELO, walked up, pulled a revolver
from beneath his folded sarong , shot the victim dead and walked away.
Palugamam; About 1Oth March:
Balan, a tax man from the finance section of the LTTE surrendered to the army
with a quantity of money in Tikkodai. It is talked about that the LTTE wanted
to question him about alleged irregularities.
Pavatkodichchenai; 19th
March: the story got around that the army had come
into the village and apprehended a man close to the LTTE. It was also speculated
that the person who had tipped off the army was a neighbour of Indian origin
who had recently come to inspect his premises and went away. As more details
emerged, people changed their mind.
Nadarajah Karunanidhi (alias Yaman)
about 33 years of age was known to be close too the LTTE. He was married and
a father. On the 18th night he came home dressed in army fatigues,
carrying several knives, a grenade and wearing 4 cyanide capsules around his
neck. He consumed a sumptuous meal prepared by his wife with a good dose of
liquor, laid aside his weapons and fell fast asleep. His wife attempted to wake
him up and send him away, but to no avail.
At 5.OO A.M the army entered the house
and a soldier placed his boot on his chest and apprehended him. Whether because
of his state or for other reasons, the 4 cyanide capsules did not help him to
end his life as the LTTE required of him. Although feeling sorry for Yaman initially,
the people subsequently came to believe that the facts suggested a pre-arranged
drama to make a surrender look like a capture. Anxiety spread quickly. Every
other person as happens in every isolated village, has no alternative but to
deal with the LTTE. Passing LTTE men may sit down and chat, ask for water, for
a meal or even ask for a nights lodging. People began to believe that
Yaman would come out with names which would be used as an excuse to harass,
detain, torture and perhaps much more. According to one informant, the ICRC
has been notified in advance.
Batticaloa Town; 23 rd March 1994:
Two policemen at a sentry point got into a heated quarrel which led to an exchange
of fire. A young school boy was hit and succumbed to his injuries. The police
hierarchy said that they felt ashamed, and to make amends, it is said, they
released the boys father whom they were holding in the Forest Department
prison. The irony about the nature of the favour was not lost. There were evidently
no charges against the father, giving the police no good reason to keep him.
Palugamam; 23rd March
1994: The LTTE at 5.3O p.m., according to the army,
threw a grenade at a passing army vehicle at Palugamam junction, which though
failed to explode. Soldiers then arrived and called out people in 1st
Divison Veerachcheni and Vanninagar. 8O people were then badly assaulted with
weapons for an hour. A number of the injured were admitted to Kaluwanchikudi
hospital. Megaran(22) was badly injured was taken to Batticaloa.
Popular belief in the village was
that no grenade was thrown but that the Army had cooked up the incident to make
a case to remain there rather than be posted to the North.
Murugan Kovilady, Verugal road,
north of Valaichchenai; 8th April 1994: About 25 army commandos were injured in an LTTE landmine explosion.
Subsequently the army ran amok burning all the 6O houses. Veeran Vairamuthu(5O)
was burnt alive in his house. About 1O villagers were seriously injured as a
result of assault. [Top]
Home | History
| Briefings | Statements
| Bulletins | Reports
| Special Reports | Publications
| Links
Copyright © UTHR 2001